Residents in Coleshill and Water Orton are once again facing a foul stench from HS2 construction works, prompting local MP Rachel Taylor to demand urgent answers and action. The odour, which has been described as 'overwhelming and unbearable,' has returned despite previous assurances from HS2 that mitigation measures would significantly reduce the impact.
MP's response to recurring problem
Rachel Taylor, MP for North Warwickshire and Bedworth, expressed deep frustration over the recurring issue. "I am deeply frustrated that residents in Coleshill and Water Orton are once again having to endure significant odour issues linked to HS2 works," she said. "In recent days, my office has received numerous reports from people describing the smell as overwhelming and unbearable, with some telling me they have been unable to open their windows. This is totally unacceptable during the hot weather."
Taylor has written to HS2's Chief Executive demanding an urgent update on the cause of the odour, the actions being taken to reduce it, and whether HS2 still stands by its previous assurances. She has also asked the Environment Agency to investigate the matter.
Background: Previous complaints and HS2's explanation
In December, HS2 addressed complaints about a 'fishy odour' affecting residents. A spokesperson explained that the smell was "linked to the use of lime to stabilise material excavated from the Bromford tunnels and is not hazardous." However, the return of the odour has raised questions about the effectiveness of the mitigation measures promised.
BirminghamLive previously visited Water Orton to speak with residents, including grandmother Gill Smith, who said she couldn't "even put the washing out." She described the smell as "horrible, it's like fish and some days you can't even put the washing out. You can't even open your windows, the smell is that bad and it's been going on for months." Smith also highlighted the broader impact on the community: "HS2 has had a big impact on people and I think it's impacted people's mental health in the village. It's got worse as the years have gone on and I think there's more to come. The smell has to be sorted out."
HS2's response and ongoing efforts
In response to the latest complaints, an HS2 spokesperson said: "We hold regular meetings with Ms Taylor and her constituents so we can listen and act on concerns. We've been transparent about the cause of the odour, which is linked to the storage and movement of excavated earth. While it poses no harm to human health, we recognise it may be unpleasant for those living nearby – particularly during the recent hot weather. We are taking decisive action to mitigate this and encourage anyone with concerns to contact us, as this helps to inform our own detailed investigations."
Impact on residents and calls for accountability
Residents have reported being unable to open windows or enjoy their gardens, with the smell intensifying during hot weather. The issue has persisted for months, affecting daily life and mental well-being. Taylor's demands for transparency and action reflect growing frustration among the community, who feel HS2 has not delivered on its promises.
Taylor concluded: "Residents deserve answers and action. You deserve confidence that everything possible is being done to minimise the foul odour that's ruining your summer. I will continue to hold HS2 to account and will update residents when I receive a response."
Next steps and community engagement
HS2 has committed to regular meetings with the MP and residents, and encourages anyone with concerns to report them directly. The Environment Agency's involvement may lead to further scrutiny of HS2's practices. Residents are urged to document any odour issues and report them to HS2 and the Environment Agency to support the investigation.
As the issue continues, the community awaits a concrete resolution, with many hoping that the promised mitigation measures will finally bring an end to the persistent odour that has blighted their daily lives.
