Birmingham boasts not one, but two major festive attractions, offering visitors a double dose of Christmas cheer. While the renowned Birmingham Christmas Market – the UK's largest German market – stretches along New Street from Victoria Square, the more intimate Christmas in Cathedral Square craft market is nestled outside St Philips Cathedral.
Though they share a seasonal glow, the two markets cater to distinctly different experiences. Knowing their unique offerings is key to planning your ideal festive outing.
Products & Shopping: Mass Appeal vs. Unique Finds
The first major difference lies in the goods on offer. The Cathedral Square craft market is a haven for unique, locally-made items. Stalls are predominantly run by small or independent businesses, meaning you're likely to discover one-of-a-kind gifts.
Highlights include 'Funny Brummie Pictures', selling Birmingham-themed pun posters from £20 and cards from £3.50. Shoppers can also find homemade earrings starting at £5 and hand-painted baubles of pets for £12.
In contrast, the Birmingham Christmas Market offers a much broader, though less bespoke, range of products. Within a short stroll, you might see light-up animal statues for £25, quirky house-shaped plant pots for £28, and thermal ski socks for £10.
Food & Drink: German Tradition vs. Posh Street Food
The culinary experiences also diverge sharply. True to its roots, the German Market is the place for traditional festive fare. Visitors can indulge in stuffed pretzels for £5, knoblauchbrot (garlic bread) for £4, roasted nuts, shokoküsse (chocolate kisses), and the legendary half-metre bratwurst.
The craft market counters with a focus on 'POSH' street food and local treats. Options include an £8 posh dog with bacon and cheese, sweet crumbles, toasted marshmallows, and cookies from local bakery stalls. It is also adjacent to Asha's restaurant, a favourite of Ed Sheeran.
Atmosphere & Amenities: Cosy Charm vs. Bustling Hub
The setting defines the vibe. The craft market benefits from a picturesque location, with the cathedral backdrop, a helter-skelter, and lit pathways creating a charming, storybook atmosphere. A major draw is The Pigeon in the Park pub, a cosy spot full of nostalgic Birmingham photos – though its popularity makes securing a seat a challenge.
The Birmingham Christmas Market is a sprawling, bustling hub with abundant seating and standing areas under covers. It features numerous bars, including a large one in Victoria Square serving double pints for £12, perfect for groups wanting to socialise close to the food stalls.
Ultimately, your choice depends on your festive priorities: for unique crafts and a quaint setting, head to Cathedral Square. For traditional German food, drink, and a vast, lively atmosphere, the main Birmingham Christmas Market is your destination.
