In a surprising twist to the January transfer window, Aston Villa are said to be engaged in talks that could see popular forward Donyell Malen depart for Italian giants AS Roma.
Shock Exit Talks for Villa's Impact Player
According to multiple reports from Italy, including from respected journalist Gianluca Di Marzio, discussions are underway between Villa and Roma regarding a potential move for the Dutch international. The proposed deal is understood to be a loan with an obligation or option to buy the player permanently.
The news comes as a shock given Malen's improved form in recent months. The 26-year-old, who joined from Borussia Dortmund for around £21 million plus add-ons in January 2025, has become a valued member of Unai Emery's squad this season. Despite only starting 13 of his 29 appearances, with a mere five Premier League starts, Malen has contributed seven goals and two assists, often making a decisive impact from the bench.
Villa's Transfer Strategy and PSR Pressures
This potential departure must be viewed in the context of Aston Villa's careful navigation of the Premier League's Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) and UEFA's Squad Cost Rules. The club has consistently had to sell players before making significant additions in recent transfer windows.
Villa have already secured one signing this month, bringing in Gremio winger Alysson for approximately £10 million. Furthermore, the club holds a strong interest in Besiktas striker Tammy Abraham and Atletico Madrid midfielder Conor Gallagher. A sale involving Malen could free up the necessary funds and squad space to pursue these targets, bolstering Emery's options for a sustained push for a Champions League place.
Weighing Up the Pros and Cons
The decision to allow Malen to leave is not straightforward. On one hand, his versatility and growing influence have been assets for a Villa side enjoying an excellent season. His absence would be felt, particularly as competition for star striker Ollie Watkins.
On the other hand, if the deal with Roma includes a significant guaranteed fee, it represents a pragmatic piece of business. It would allow Villa to reinvest in areas Emery deems critical for the final months of the campaign. The report states that Roma are now seeking the player's approval, indicating Villa may be open to the move.
For Malen, a move could offer the promise of more regular starting football, something he has found elusive at Villa Park, having been controversially left out of their Champions League squad last season. The coming days will reveal whether these shock talks develop into a concrete January transfer.
