Lidl has resubmitted plans to City of Wolverhampton Council to demolish the former Goldthorn Hotel on Penn Road and build a new supermarket, following the expiration of earlier permission granted in 2023. The initial approval, narrowly passed by the council's planning committee in 2022, lapsed earlier this year after delays in land acquisition.
Details of the Proposed Development
The new application seeks to construct a 2,000 square metre store with a 93-bay car park. Lidl says the development would create 40 full-time jobs. The supermarket chain had previously received planning permission in January 2023, but the project failed to proceed due to unresolved land purchase issues, as confirmed by the company in April.
History and Controversy
The plans have been controversial from the outset. In 2022, the council's planning committee approved them by a narrow margin, despite 73 objections and a 105-signature petition. The Victorian Society formally objected, arguing that the hotel is “one of the last references to the historic streetcape” in that part of Wolverhampton. Many objectors also cited safety concerns, noting the site is near an accident black spot.
Heritage Concerns
The Goldthorn Hotel, originally built in the late 19th century as a home for John Rollings, director of Star Cycles, Cars and Commercial Vehicles, is a non-listed building of historic interest. Council conservation officers described its loss as “regrettable” but supported the 2022 plans. Planners noted that “extensions and additions have somewhat subsumed the main building and much of its architectural character has been harmed or lost.”
Council Support
Despite heritage concerns, council officers recommended approval, stating: “Whilst there would be some impact on visual amenity and the loss of a heritage asset, the proposals would result in a good quality scheme which would not result in any highway concerns and are therefore considered appropriate.” They highlighted the potential for “significant investment and new jobs.”
Next Steps
The application is now under review by City of Wolverhampton Council. A decision is expected in the coming months. If approved, construction could begin in 2027.
