A parent has expressed outrage after their son was fined £500 for dropping a cigarette butt in Southwark, London, despite being physically prevented from picking it up by an enforcement officer.
Incident Details
The parent wrote to the Guardian newspaper, explaining that the enforcement officer stopped the son from retrieving the cigarette butt and told him he would avoid a fine only by providing identification. The officer also threatened to call the police if the son refused to comply.
After providing ID, the son was promptly issued a fixed-penalty notice (FPN) of £500. The parent argued that this amount is higher than typical fines for dangerous offences like speeding.
Inconsistencies in Fines
The parent highlighted how fines vary dramatically between London boroughs. In Barnet, the same offence costs £100, but just across the border in Enfield, the fine rises to £500. This 400% increase for the same act committed a few yards apart was described as disproportionate and unfair.
Official Responses
The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs stated that litter louts must be stopped and that enforcement should be proportionate, allowing councils to focus on the worst offenders. Southwark Council defended its firm approach, noting that littering is a key concern for residents. APCOA, the contractor carrying out patrols, said its officers follow standard operating procedures, which were adhered to in this instance. APCOA also confirmed it does not retain the proceeds from FPNs.
Challenging the Fine
Southwark Council advises that anyone who believes a fixed penalty notice was issued incorrectly can challenge it within 14 days of receipt.
