Bridgerton Author Julia Quinn Weighs In on Hyacinth and Gregory Recasting Debate
Julia Quinn, the author behind the beloved Bridgerton book series, has now addressed the ongoing conversation about whether actors Florence Hunt and Will Tilston should be recast for their characters' future seasons. This discussion has been sparked by fans on social media, with some expressing concerns about the actors transitioning from child roles to romantic leads.
Background on the Recasting Conversation
Florence Hunt and Will Tilston have portrayed Hyacinth and Gregory Bridgerton since the show's inception, starting when they were just 12 and 13 years old. With the Netflix series planning to adapt all eight books, each focusing on a different sibling, questions have arisen about whether these two youngest actors will lead their own seasons. Bridgerton has a history of recasting, as seen with Francesca Bridgerton, where Ruby Stokes was replaced by Hannah Dodd due to scheduling conflicts.
Some fans argue it would be weird or unethical for Hunt and Tilston to take on romantic storylines after growing up on screen. However, Julia Quinn disagrees, pointing out the practical timeline of the show's production.
Julia Quinn's Perspective on Aging and Recasting
In an interview with Us Weekly, Quinn highlighted how the actors have matured. When I saw them again at the premiere, they were both drinking wine. They’re both 18 now and Will was there with his girlfriend, she said. She emphasized that by the time Hyacinth and Gregory's seasons are filmed, the actors will be well into their twenties, given that each season takes around 18 months to produce.
Quinn also shared her personal experience writing the characters' books, noting, As a writer, it was hard to write those two books at first. I really had to let them grow up in my mind a bit and that was hard for both of them. She believes that seeing child stars age is a common occurrence in entertainment, making it acceptable for Hunt and Tilston to continue their roles.
Fan Reactions and Future Possibilities
On social media platforms like X/Twitter and Reddit, fans have voiced strong opinions. While a minority call for recasting, many supporters argue that Hunt and Tilston are perfect for their characters and deserve to lead their own seasons. One fan wrote, I cannot, will not, do not want to accept a recast for Hyacinth, this is the best Hyacinth Bridgerton we could ever have. Others suggest that if recasting occurs, it should align with the actors' wishes.
Florence Hunt has expressed enthusiasm about potentially portraying Hyacinth's story, stating in an interview, If I ever got the chance—and we actually have no idea—like, if I ever got the chance to do that story, I'd be over the moon. However, seasons 7 and 8, which would focus on Hyacinth and Gregory, have not been officially confirmed by Netflix, though executive producer Shonda Rhimes has indicated plans for all eight seasons.
Timeline and Production Details
Showrunner Jess Brownell has explained that each Bridgerton season requires approximately 18 months to create. With upcoming seasons set to focus on Eloise and Francesca, it is estimated that Hyacinth and Gregory's stories might not air until 2029 or 2030, if the series is renewed. This extended timeline means Hunt and Tilston will be significantly older by then, potentially alleviating some fan concerns.
As the debate continues, the future of these characters remains uncertain, but Julia Quinn's insights and fan support suggest a strong case for keeping the original actors in their iconic roles.
