Major changes are on the horizon for local government in Worcestershire, with a new business case suggesting that a single unitary authority could deliver millions in savings for the county.
The Financial Case for a Single Council
Worcestershire County Council is championing the 'One Worcestershire' model, a proposal that would see the county council and the six district councils replaced by one single unitary authority. According to a business plan released this week, this model could achieve substantial financial benefits.
The figures are compelling: £12 million in savings could be realised in just the second year of operating as a single council, with that figure climbing to a significant £32 million by the third year.
In contrast, the council's analysis argues that an alternative model involving two unitary authorities, favoured by several districts, would still require spending £11.5 million in year two and would only begin generating modest savings of £2.75 million in year three.
Political Backing and Heated Criticism
The business case received formal backing from the full council in a meeting on Thursday. However, the proposal was met with strong criticism from some councillors, revealing a deep political divide.
Conservative councillor Karen May did not hold back, describing the report as "one of the worst reports I have ever read" and criticising its lack of "factual evidence" and ambition.
Liberal Democrat councillor Dan Boatright-Greene questioned the report's independence, remarking, "This document backs up your arguments because you paid for it to be like that – that's what consultants do." He also threatened to report the council to the Information Commissioner's Office for not providing him with requested information.
The Wider Context and Councillor Frustration
The push for reform comes as part of a national move towards devolution. Deputy chairman Paul Bennett warned that the projected savings "could be thrown out of the window" when powers are eventually transferred to an elected mayor, a key part of the Labour government's devolution plans.
Green councillor Martin Allen expressed concern for residents, stating they "must be disgusted as they had no idea this was coming." He abstained from the vote, claiming that "nothing you or I will make a scrap of difference."
Council leader Jo Monk voiced a sentiment of frustration shared by some, saying, "None of us wanted this. Labour forced it upon us." This highlights the external pressure driving the local government reorganisation, setting the stage for further debate as other districts prepare to unveil their own proposals.
