As Birmingham City reach the one-third mark of the Championship season, the signs are becoming increasingly encouraging, particularly following their performances between the October and November international breaks.
A haul of nine points from their last six outings represents form that is close to play-off standard, though the team must still make up for a sluggish September. While new additions like Christoph Klarer and Jay Stansfield have adapted seamlessly, how has the rest of the squad fared? Alex Dicken has delivered his comprehensive player ratings for the opening 15 league fixtures.
Defensive and Goalkeeping Analysis
In goal, Ryan Allsop received a 6 after a series of performances that didn't feature a catalogue of errors, though a notable mistake against Sheffield Wednesday ultimately cost him his starting position. His replacement, James Beadle, earned a 7 for growing into a commanding presence, securing three clean sheets in his seven appearances.
The defensive line shows both strength and concern. Christoph Klarer stands out with an 8.5, establishing himself as the team's most dependable player and a rock at the back. Alongside him, Phil Neumann scored a 7, with the team conceding just eight goals in the ten games he has featured in.
However, Jack Robinson's disastrous start earned him the lowest rating of a 3, marred by two red cards and an own goal in only four appearances. Ethan Laird was rated a 7 and was considered the best full-back before a hamstring injury sidelined him in late September.
Midfield and Attacking Verdicts
The midfield has seen several players settle in well. Tomoki Iwata, now excelling at right-back, earned a 7.5 for his whole-hearted displays that have significantly improved the team. Paik Seung-ho and Tommy Doyle both received 7s, with the former showing flashes of brilliance and the latter finally cementing his place after a slow start.
In attack, Patrick Roberts is a classy operator, securing an 8 for his influential return, having created more chances (19) than any teammate. Jay Stansfield also earned an 8 for a fantastic start, contributing to nine goals in all competitions.
There are others still finding their feet. Demarai Gray received a 7 for his 'teasing' start which has yielded three goals, while Kyogo Furuhashi was given a 5.5 as he continues to wait for his first goal, having missed nine big chances.
Overall Season Outlook
The ratings paint a picture of a squad with a solid core and clear standouts, but also one with definite areas for growth. The encouraging form since October shows what this Birmingham City team is capable of, but consistency will be the key to mounting a serious challenge as the season progresses. With influential players like Roberts and Stansfield in form, and others like Doyle now integrated, the foundation for a successful campaign is being laid.
