In a surprising twist to the January transfer window, it has emerged that Aston Villa considered a shock move for Everton midfielder James Garner. The Villans, who had a relatively quiet window with just four signings, were keen on bolstering their squad with the talented workhorse.
Villa's Transfer Window Activity
Aston Villa's business in January was modest, focusing on strategic acquisitions. They kicked off with the signing of Brazilian winger Alysson from Gremio for approximately £10 million, followed by a similar investment in 17-year-old FC Metz wonderkid Brian Madjo. The club then secured an £18.5 million deal with Besiktas to bring back Tammy Abraham and arranged a loan for ex-Villa midfielder Douglas Luiz from Juventus.
Despite these additions, many fans felt more could have been done, with financial constraints limiting Villa's competitiveness in the market. However, the story could have been different if certain opportunities had materialised.
Interest in James Garner
According to reports from The Athletic, Aston Villa held a strong interest in signing James Garner from Everton. Unai Emery was particularly keen on the midfielder, who had only six months remaining on his Everton contract at the time. This situation potentially made him available for a reduced fee or even as a free agent in the summer.
Villa's admiration for Garner stemmed from his impressive work rate, versatility, and overall talent. The club saw him as a valuable addition to their midfield options. However, their pursuit was cut short when Garner opted to sign a new long-term contract with Everton, committing his future to the Hill Dickinson Stadium.
Garner's Career and Impact
James Garner, who joined Everton from Manchester United in 2022 for around £15 million including add-ons, has developed into a pivotal player for the Toffees. Primarily operating in defensive midfield, he has also showcased his adaptability by playing in full-back roles and as a central midfielder.
At 24 years old, Garner's performances have even sparked discussions about a potential surprise call-up to the England national team. His defensive contributions this season place him in the top 14 per cent of Premier League midfielders, and he has added two goals and three assists in the 2025/26 campaign.
Contract Clarifications for Villa Duo
In other Aston Villa news, confusion surrounding the contract lengths of Youri Tielemans and Ross Barkley has been resolved. Many supporters believed Tielemans' deal was set to expire in June 2027, raising concerns about his future. Similarly, fans thought Barkley might leave at the end of the current season.
However, investigations by The Athletic's Jacob Tanswell reveal that Tielemans' contract actually runs until June 2028, providing a significant boost for the club. Barkley, too, has an additional year on his deal, meaning he will remain at Villa Park until June 2027 unless sold. This clarity offers reassurance to the Villa Park faithful regarding the squad's stability.
