Hidden Speed Camera in Newton Abbot Sparks Outrage Among Drivers and Councillors
A speed camera located on Ashburton Road in Newton Abbot, Devon, has been labeled as "unfair and hidden" after it caught more than 6,000 drivers, leading to widespread criticism and a formal challenge by local councillors. The device, installed to enforce a 30mph limit, is now at the center of a debate over its visibility and adherence to national standards.
Councillors Question Camera's Legitimacy and Fairness
Conservative councillors Phil Bullivant, representing Bradley, and Alex Hall, from Buckland and Milber, have put forward a motion demanding answers about the camera's operation. They argue that while speeding is unacceptable, especially in residential areas, enforcement must be transparent and fair to the public.
The motion emphasizes that the process for administering sanctions requires public understanding and perceived appropriateness. It calls on the highway authority to confirm several key points:
- Whether the 30mph speed limit is appropriate for the location.
- If cheaper engineering solutions could be more effective than the camera.
- If the signage is correct and legal.
- If the camera is sufficiently visible and not obscured by vegetation.
Complaints Highlight Issues with Camera Placement and Low-Speed Fines
Many drivers who received tickets have complained about the camera's placement on a lamppost with minimal signage, leading to poor visual awareness. Additionally, there have been numerous reports of proceedings initiated for speeds less than 35mph, which raises questions about the enforcement thresholds.
The motion specifically asks: "What was the basis for the camera installation, who decided on the parameters for the actual installation, how many proceedings have been instigated for speeds of 35mph or less, and does the installation meet national standards for speed camera locations?"
Background and Guidelines on Speed Enforcement
The camera was installed by the Devon and Cornwall Police Road Safety Team, in collaboration with Devon County Council and the Vision Zero South West partnership. National guidelines typically recommend a fixed penalty fine or a speed awareness course when speeds exceed 10% plus 2mph above the limit. In a 30mph zone, this threshold is 35mph, making the complaints about sub-35mph fines particularly contentious.
This controversy highlights ongoing concerns about road safety measures and their implementation, urging authorities to ensure that enforcement tools are both effective and justly applied to maintain public trust.
