A Birmingham councillor has voiced strong opposition to plans that would see a former pub site transformed into residential accommodation. Gemma Guttridge, representing Frankley Great Park for the Reform Party, has criticised the proposal for the Lickey Banker pub, which closed its doors in 2022 according to CAMRA.
Concerns over community loss
The application seeks a change of use for the ground floor of the former pub to create five self-contained flats. While acknowledging the need for housing, Councillor Guttridge argued on social media that the proposal raises significant concerns for the local community.
She highlighted the potential loss of a venue that could have housed community services, youth activities, or other beneficial initiatives for the area. The councillor also noted that the pub's closure eliminated a source of local employment and economic activity.
"A successful pub, café, or community venue can attract visitors, support local jobs, and increase footfall for nearby businesses," she said. "Rather than losing another community facility, efforts should be focused on encouraging investment in local amenities that improve residents' quality of life and help address social isolation."
Previous refusal for retail use
The same applicant had previously sought permission to change the pub into a convenience retail unit. That proposal was refused by the council last year, with planning officers citing concerns about the development being a main town centre use outside a designated local centre. They noted a lack of evidence regarding available space in nearby centres and an overconcentration of retail in the area.
Councillor Guttridge added: "Residents deserve developments that are appropriate, well-planned, and genuinely beneficial to the area – and this proposal does not yet demonstrate that." She also pointed out that the site had already been proposed as a shop, but similar facilities already exist in the area, and more housing is already being planned across Frankley Great Park.
A consultation on the plans for the flats is currently underway.
